IDPF at BEA: Tension Around the Proposed W3C Merger

Going…going… At what may well have been the last International Digital Publishing Forum (IDPF) conference, a proposed merger of IDPF and the World Wide Web Consortium cast a chill in Chicago.

Looking for direction, what may be the last IDPF "DigiCon" conference is at Chicago's McCormick Place West as BookExpo America opens -- and as IDPF's future is debated. Image - Porter Anderson
Image – Porter Anderson

By Porter Anderson, Editor-in-Chief | @Porter_Anderson

Update: Since the original publication of this article at Publishing Perspectives, a great deal of discussion has gone into the question of the IDPF-W3C merger, an overtake, basically, of a publishing-standards outfit by a Web-standards outfit—both groups familiar with each other from some four years of collaborative work. For a recent perspective on the issue, I recommend Tzviya Siegman’s piece at Medium, “An Optimistic View.” — PA

‘Hello, We Must Be Going’: Is IDPF on the Way Out?

In its early going, the “Midwestern BookExpo America” (BEA) seems punctuated with questions.

“Why Chicago?” is the umbrella inquiry you hear rain-dampened cohorts putting to each other on the vast escalators of the McCormick Place West exhibition complex.

Press statements from Reed Exhibitions are buoyant with westward-ho! good spirits:

“The move to Chicago has resulted in almost 1,000 more attendees from Illinois and a significant increase in attendance from States including Michigan, Missouri, Iowa, Ohio, Kentucky, and Minnesota. The uptick reinforces the purpose of a Midwest convention, broadening the reach and exposure for independent booksellers, publishers, and authors.”

Of course, that move to Chicago is also cutting back on attendees from New York City, American publishing’s hub and BEA’s customary base. And some who make it to Chicago may be surprised to find themselves homesick for the Jacob Javits Center. This year stands as a one-time expedition across the Hudson: BEA is set to return to the Javits in Manhattan next year, running May 31, June 1 and 2 there.

On Tuesday (May 10), roughly 350 attendees gathered for the annual pre-BEA conference produced by the International Digital Publishing Forum (IDPF). #IDPFDigiCon, as it’s hashtagged, isn’t to be confused with that “con” of a different demeanor, BookCon — the boisterous, mostly-YA consumer-facing entertainment event from Lance Fensterman’s ReedPOP on Saturday, featuring Veronica Roth and others.

An animated Tim Berners-Lee speaks at the IDPF conference on publishing and Web technology. Image - Porter Anderson
An animated Tim Berners-Lee speaks at the IDPF conference on publishing and Web technology. Image – Porter Anderson

Nevertheless, we fanboys and -girls of Sir Tim Berners-Lee, the man behind the World Wide Web, were eager to see and hear him speak on “Realizing the Vision of Publishing Technology Being Web Technology.”

But by the time “TBL” took the stage, a cloud hung over the confab. Berners-Lee also has established the World Wide Web Consortium, called W3C, of course, and a part of the motivation for his appearance at the IDPF show, it turns out, was the formal announcement of a proposal to have IDPF (the agency for EPUB standards) be subsumed into W3C.

While early news of this idea was published in late April by Publishers Weekly, the IDPF leadership didn’t seem to anticipate the pushback that quickly was developing from some of its members — especially not at a midday news conference called to elaborate on the idea, with Berners-Lee on hand.

From left, W3C's Tim Berners-Lee, and IDPF's Bill McCoy and George Kerscher at Tuesday's news conference on the proposed IFPF-W3C merger. Image: Porter Anderson
From left, W3C’s Tim Berners-Lee, and IDPF’s Bill McCoy and George Kerscher at Tuesday’s news conference on the proposed IFPF-W3C merger. Image: Porter Anderson
Misgivings About Merging

W3C CEO Jeff Jaffe spoke to the merger’s likely ability to “accelerate the convergence” of Web and publishing standards and of how the original inception of the Web itself wasn’t unlike publishing in many ways.

Jeff Jaffe, W3C CEO, speaks at Tuesday's news conference. Image: Porter Anderson
Jeff Jaffe, W3C CEO, speaks at Tuesday’s news conference. Image: Porter Anderson

“When people author books in the future, the nature of curated books will change,” he said. One of the biggest advantages, he told the news conference, will be making Web documents portable.

It was OverDrive President and CEO Steve Potash who, during the news conference, asked IDPF heads Bill McCoy and George Kerscher to clarify just what voting stance IDPF members would have in W3C if those members approve the integration of the two groups.

McCoy spoke readily of the importance of developing a “horizontal solution” to many issues around EPUB standards, something he sees more easily implemented by the Open Web platform standards of the W3C, a much larger body with a fully international reach.

McCoy, noting that the kind of question Potash was raising was for the membership meeting to comeon Wednesday (May 11) here at BEA, promised an “open and transparent” process in terms of membership comment. But when pressed by Publishers Weekly’s Cal Reid, he conceded that the plan involves IDPF being “absorbed.” It will effectively be lost as an entity of its own, its remaining members instead functioning in a “publishing activity group” within W3C.

All parties are emphasizing that there is no hard decision yet — and no declared deadline for one. The input of the W3C and IDPF memberships is to be registered and carefully considered.

But if a proposed merger between IDPF and the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) comes about by the projected January 2017 date, it’s questionable that there will be another IDPF conference.

Quick Delivery, Listening Up

All of this made it peculiarly unsettling that Berners-Lee’s keynote to the conference plenary was at many points not fully coherent to many in the room. This is a man seriously respected by so many of us for his conceptualization while at CERN of the content management and hypertext scheme we know now as the World Wide Web. It’s his work that makes the Internet intelligible to most of us.

He has spoken in the past of having reached a “higher level of abstraction” when he conceived of the idea in 1989, 20 years after the advent of the Internet, he noted. As he spoke from several levels of abstraction at times, his infectious exuberance for a convergence of publishing and the Internet generated fast, continual hand gestures, his head bobbing, a speaker busy with his ideas.

But for all the zeal of this fine personality’s reverie, one expert observer who has worked with both IDPF and W3C pointed out that the robust IDPF tweet stream fell largely quiet, not because the crowd was wrapped up in the talk but because it was next to impossible to capture a full, rational line from Berners-Lee’s remarks.

“The convergence between books and the Web is really, really important,” he told the audience in a moment of slower pace. But given to a kind of declaration-then-digression pattern of delivery, Berners-Lee didn’t get many of his other thoughts over with such grace to the audience, which strained to catch his asides in the pell-mell rush of his commentary from the podium.

The rest of the conference day was comparatively pedestrian and at times given to more listing of what great things data can mean to publishing than most publishers today still need to hear. A highlight was Kobo’s Michael Tamlyn, whose now familiar message that ebook adoption is being driven by users in their 50s, 60s, and 70s (his “silver foxes”) has real currency. There was good programming emphasis on issues of accessiblity and libraries, as well.

And in the news conference about the merger question, Berners-Lee spoke much less than did McCoy, Kerscher, and Jaffe. But when he did speak up there, Berners-Lee had a more purposeful delivery than he’d used onstage in the conference: “When organizations work together,” he told the news conference, “there’s no free lunch. It must be good, it must be fair, and it must be yesterday.”

There’s more: Read the full story at Publishing Perspectives

By Porter Ander­son

Originally published at

Joining us at Frankfurt Book Fair’s Business Club?


Authors: To subscribe to The Hot Sheet—the essential industry newsletter for authors from Jane Friedman and Porter Anderson—click here and enjoy our 30-day free trial. (Ask me for a special discount code.)

 TheHotSheet 600 2015-03-08_18-54-25

600 x 200 TEP this one

600 PP Rights confab lined

600 Nielsen Romance Summit banner better

WDC NYC 2016 6OO X 120

600 BANNER Biz Club 2016

Leave a Reply